Study, Prepare, Succeed

875 Law Blog Medialog Political Blog Tech Blog Trolling Through Life™ Blog Unplugged and Uncut Blog

What if Stan had Twitter? Considering Stella Creasy and Mike Weatherley

There have been a number of reports in recent weeks of where Members of Parliament have had threats against them. These have been reported on the BBC and include Stella Creasy and most recently Mike Weatherley.

The media are acting shocked about this, but for me this is just another one of those scares that might lead to an inquiry on links between Twitter and delinquency, like happened when TV went mainstream. Maybe there needs to be a ‘Stan test,’ which is that abuse on Twitter should only be prosecuted if it would be prosecuted for printed communication and goes beyond what is lawful to hear on the music channels? David Cameron has said this week that all media should be treated equally. So if Stella Creasy’s trollers would be prosecuted, would Eminem’s mythical Stan (in the explicit video below) be brought before the courts?

The law on whether a message on the Internet is threatening should now be clear. This is what the Crown Prosecution Service’s website says:

Communications which may constitute credible threats of violence to the person may fall to be considered under section 16 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 if the threat is a threat to kill within the meaning of that provision. Other credible threats of violence to the person may fall to be considered under section 4 of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 if they amount to a course of conduct within the meaning of that provision and there is sufficient evidence to establish the necessary state of knowledge. Credible threats of violence to the person or damage to property may also fall to be considered under section 1 of the Malicious Communications Act 1988, which prohibits the sending of an electronic communication which conveys a threat, or section 127 of the Communications Act 2003 which prohibits the sending of messages of a menacing character by means of a public telecommunications network.

One could argue that this clearly applies in the cases of Stella Creasy. Stella Creasy was told by one Twitter user by the name of @rapey1: ” i will rape you tomorrow at 9pm. Shall we meet near your house?????””

I have been a victim of rape, and whilst I have developed a thick skin since being in public life, in my view there is a difference between someone being told they should be raped and a threat like Stella Creasy experience which gives a time and a place, so might be reasonable to assume in the average person it would cause apprehension and MPs may be no different. The CPS guidance continues:

However, before proceeding with such a prosecution, prosecutors should heed the words of the Lord Chief Justice in Chambers v DPP [2012] EWH2 2157 (Admin) where he said: “… a message which does not create fear or apprehension in those to whom it is communicated, or may reasonably be expected to see it, falls outside [section 127(i)(a)], for the simple reason that the message lacks menace.” (Paragraph 30)

One might expect Stella Creasy to be easily covered by this due to the detail in the message she received. But in the case of Mike Weatherby a message wasn’t even directed at him as the person directed it at @pinknews. The message said “KILL WEATHERBY,” which in noway compares with what was personally directed at Stella Creasy. This is what the CPS guidance says:

As a general rule, threats which are not credible should not be prosecuted, unless they form part of a campaign of harassment specifically targeting an individual within the meaning of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 (see category (2) below). Where there is evidence of hostility or prejudice, prosecutors should pay particular regard to sections 28-32 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 and section 145 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 (increase in sentences for racial and religious aggravation) and section 146 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 (increase in sentences for aggravation related to disability, sexual orientation or transgender identity).

This paragraph makes the Mike Weatherby situation more difficult to deal with. It clearly does not amount to harassment as there was only one in-the-moment instance. It was aggravated by factors relating to sexual orientation. Might it therefore make sense to bring any prosecution under the Public Order Act 1986 as happened with Liam Stacey?

Jonathan Bishop

Information technology executive, researcher, writer. If you study and prepare then success will follow.

Recommended Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *